Creative Score Reviews

Creative Score delivers a thorough and detailed report, and some of its recommendations are genuinely insightful. However, the overall analysis can feel contradictory and confusing. For instance, it suggests changing my headline, yet simultaneously lists it as a strength—leaving me unsure which advice to follow. At this stage, it’s clear the tool still requires manual interpretation and input to be truly useful.

There are also limitations when uploading web pages. You have to extract and upload the full page manually, and sites with motion effects aren’t properly detected. The report labeled my animated site as “plain” and recommended adding effects—which was ironic, considering the animations were already there. Capturing screenshots of animated or image-sequence-based sites is also problematic, with no reliable workaround.

On the plus side, I appreciate that the report can be exported, saving me from clicking through the dashboard repeatedly. Unfortunately, the exported text isn’t editable or copyable, which makes it difficult to repurpose or refine the insights. It’s a missed opportunity, as the report loses much of its utility without that flexibility

I uploaded two items for analysis: (1) a homepage for a client website; and (2) a downloadable report asset (in the form a three slides).

For the homepage (1), I uploaded a screenshot of the entire page. For (2), I uploaded a three-page PNG formatted file....the analysis only appears to have considered the first page, which is less relevant than reviewing the full document. It has options to identify what Media Type you are uploading (including Digital Brochure/Leaflet and Presentation). I'm not sure how to upload a full document for this analysis where it would analyze more than the first page.

The results were impressive for the homepage. Lots of actionable insight for each. For a company with few people, that may be enough to be worthwhile. For a company with many decision makers or clients that need committees to make decisions, this needs to be easier to share.

Recommendations:
1. Export all recommendations to PDF (NOTE: Garry mentioned on a review response here that this was launching in September. I do not see how to export today.
2. This only accepts PNG of JPG/JPEG formats. PDF would be great to review documents.
3. Collaboration...today, you can invite team members. It would be nice to assign specific recommendations to team members and keep track of when updates are made.
4. I tried to review the FAQ in their online Help Center, but it currently takes me to a 404 website

Overall, I think this could be a solid tool once they work out a number of issues.

I really like Creative Score. It’s a very helpful tool that gives me clear and actionable feedback to improve my creative assets. The suggestions are easy to understand, well explained, and I can apply them right away. It saves me time and helps me optimize my ads and content much more effectively.

I love the fact that Creative Score gives you a rating on your creatives as well as on your copy. Plus it teaches you why you need to implement certain strategies and text to improve sales, lead generation etc.

So far it meets all my expectations, and since this App is brand new, I would like to see the option to analyze Reels as well.

My biggest problem is that English is my third language and I don't have a strong command on this language. So Creative Score solves my problem in creating a copy that is more appealing to new leads and clients. Another problem that it solves is showing how the biggest Companies are designing their ads and landing pages to drive traffic and sales. It lays out the steps easy and concise.

You get this for the creative efficiency and effectiveness, to reduce wasted ad spend and enhance roi. But you can use this for game design such as for game assets and game art and storytelling as long as they keep things modular, etc.