GREAT (and somewhat frustrating)
I LOVE the idea and general functionality of the tool -- have only used the Media Review option so far, and generally it is great. I am facing several key issues, though:
(1) Commenting on a Video or PDF or Image is not nested; it doesn't go several levels deep. You can only keep commenting on the original first comment-post.
(2) The timecode-sorting of all the comments is only possible from end-to-start. I would really want to see a Start-to-End sort, so it follows the video (makes much more logical sense, to me).
(3) and this one is HUGE... a lot of the ICON elements are misaligned. I click on the EDIT icon (next to the Delete icon), and instead of editing, it deletes the entire comment. I click on Reply, and instead it opens the EDIT. etc... This has happened many times now, both in the side-by-side Video-Comments view and in the Video followed by Comments (underneath) view... This really needs to get sorted...
If some of the above gets solved (and possibly more - I have played with the tool for only a few hours so far), then it is an amazingly powerful tool, similar to Frame.io which I have used extensively before.
Hope that the tool will keep improving!
Best wishes to Chipper and the team,
Meindert
Chipper_Whelm
May 9, 2024Thanks for your kind review, Meindert. We appreciate your feedback.
For what it's worth: Your 1st and 2nd points are actually solved. We just resolved the comment threading issue this morning, and the comment sorting is already available (click on the dropdown above the comments to rearrange the order).
I appreciate the feedback on your third point. I'll get looking at that today!